Continuing improvement: What are HBG doing to become better?


Whilst we are a small team of volunteers who work on Herefordshire Boardgamers club in our spare time, we continually strive for improvement year upon year and want the hobby to be shared with as many individuals in the County as possible and also further afield! (Please check out our events!) We also invite you to read our testimonials to attest to the true power of board gaming on individuals in our community!

We also share all the lessons we have learned on our knowledge base to help other communities do better quicker. https://www.herefor.games/knowledge

Surveys:

We have reviewed our annual surveys since 2023. Information was collected from approximately 100 surveys. We also invited participants to raise improvements/concerns as part of a wider survey.

2022 information here Needs Survey feedback (November 22) – Herefordshire Board Gamers

The common themes for areas of improvement for HBG are as follows:

Accessible venues (Mentioned five times)
Heavier games in the library (Mentioned twice)
Better Library website (Mentioned twice)
Rotate games /Players (Mentioned twice)
Layout (Mentioned twice)

*We just want to note that this feedback was submitted as part of positive responses, for example, the rest of the survey was highly rated with a high chance of ‘recommending us to a friend’ and they were answering the question What could we improve? Change? or What would you like us to change, improve or add?
There was only one truly negative survey and that was related to online gaming, which we generally have a harder time keeping up to our wanted standards. This response has not been included below.



Feedback themes and follow-up actions:

  • Would like some slightly heavier / meatier games, euros etc. (On HBG nights and in the library).
    • Ongoing improvement-  We have a great range of games but we definitely have more on the lighter end, we have a limited budget and rely on donations from individuals and publishers to round the library out.  We do try to invest in some new titles (not kick starters) recently we got some of the first copies of Hot Streak and Magic Athlete for example.
    • Where we see second hand opportunities or donations we are including them in the library
  • Rotate groups more as you can end up on the same table all night.
  • Rotate some of the players to improve interaction throughout the group.
    • Ongoing improvement- We are definitely aware of this and will aim to do better. Some folks like to stay with people they know and scheduling games to end at similar times is tough. We are now clearer with checking with guests if they want to ‘mingle’ or not. Note: This is dependent on the games, teachers and players available at any one time.
  • A better way to see which games are available to borrow.
    • Partially Solved- We have a new website for the library which should show what we have – but not what is in stock. https://www.herefor.games/library
  • More frequent sessions on a weekend.
    • Ongoing improvement-  We currently do 1 a month (Sunday) and 1 extra a quarter (Saturday). We’ll do another survey soon to see which day  and what the demand is. As volunteers we need to be mindful of our capacity though.
  • More accessible venues.
  • Keep working on pubs getting ramps?
    • Ongoing improvement- we now provide HBG events at accessible venues at least once a quarter. To do this we have used grant and-self funding with the aim to add more accessible venues to the rota beyond once a quarter.
    • 100% agree. Keeping events free and venues accessible is a major challenge though.
  • Sometimes, during the winter the heating could be better.
    • Where we know there will be challenges with heating we will let people know on the event and social media. The main venues (The Herdsman and Richmond Place tend to never be cold).
  • Posts assume a lot of knowledge; ‘Blood on the Clock Tower’? It makes me feel daft or stupid.
  • Explain games mentioned in posts, Don’t assume folks know the names of lots of games.
    • We try to include a how-to link in the comments when introducing new games.
    • Depending on the posts I will explain games however social media posts often need to be kept short. The after-event posts I only name the games so folks can cross reference what they played.
    • Knowing the names of lots of games isn’t required nor is gaming knowledge, we bring a large game library and game teachers to get you started regardless of your knowledge.
    • We do need to be better at using caption / Alt text in images.( Which will help with this and also screen readers)
  • Posts that say over 30 people attended mean I am concerned about coming as I am uneasy walking alone into rooms with large groups…
    • We share photos of the venue and full walkthroughs so individuals can plan and be aware.
      What is a games night? – Herefordshire Board Gamers
    • We share attendance to show people they won’t be alone at the event. We have a lot higher attendance than RSVPS across Facebook and Instagram (five to ten times higher) so it important so share our attendance so people know they should be able to get a game of their choice and do not attend thinking they will be alone.
    • If there any specific support actions we can take please do message us.
  • Lots of games tables are great, but please spread them out in the room (like the back of The Herdsman) rather than crowding in one corner…. Close tables means that movement is harder and noise levels higher/more immediate
    • We try to lay out tables and chairs in the venue as best we can using the space and putting the louder party style games at one side of the room.
  • Maybe some different venues, perhaps on the outskirts of Hereford.
    • We want to work in partnership with local communities to help generate interest and help folks find the events. In 2025/ 2026 we have been supporting Game of Scones and Wye Valley Gaming community in running events outside Hereford City, in Ross for example.
  • Different venues some venues aren’t great for board gaming (sticky tables).
    • Solved: We now have table cloths and coasters at all our events to help protect the games. The stickiest table has also been replaced by one of our venues.
  • More inclusive and less cliques. Majority of members/guests are male.
    • More Inclusion- I would love any feedback on this however a lot of work has been done to date on including the LGBTIA+ community and also individuals with disabilities, including physical disabilities and visual or cortical visual impairment (we have 11 dedicated Visual Impairment Friendly games).
    • Equipment has been purchased for individuals with physical impairments/disabilities such as card holders and height adjustable tables for wheel chair users.
    • We have adopted name badges to include pronouns (Colour coded) as well as the person’s name.
    • Carefully curated range of games
    • Neurodiversity and how the environment affects these individuals is an ongoing area we are aware of, ie. background noise.
    • Less cliques- please see above points on group and people rotation and actions.
    • Additionally with cliques, we are aware these can effect the enjoyment of folks at games night and we will do our best to support all guests so it does not impact, including greeting new guests and teaching them suitable games. However we cannot and should not make folks who want a quiet night with friends mingle or meet new people. We have a lot of neurodivergent people, people recovering from a long week at work they may want to stay and play with their friends for the first part of the night or all of it.
    • Male domination: dependent on the night, but we feel the majority of our session have a good mix.
    • In context, for the hobby of gaming males tend to be the majority. However HBG has a great diversity which can vary all the way to 50/50 split. Lots of our non-male guests do attend alone which is reassuing that we are doing something right. We have a new contact system launching soon which should give choice and support in asking questions to a committee member of your choice (who may be more like you) this should help with support and feedback
    • The committiee includes folks from various backgrounds and life experiences and we have steering groups to support us.
    • More information on accessibility and inclusion Accessibility and Inclusion – Herefordshire Board Gamers

Here for Games con 2025 (there were less feedback forms this year):

  • Closing time
    • We will make it clear and also be clearer on how long you have to finish your game.

Here for Games Con 2024 Feedback:

  • Better explanation on some of the stands, the painting zone especially wasn’t sure if we could just get stuck in. Nor how to participate in the play to win games.
    • Actioned: Signage has been improved, as has the introductions.
  • Having more than one copy of the longer Play-to-win games (like Wyrmspan) so more people can play it for their full game.
    • Actioned: We have 2 copies of most of the play to wins. We’ve also changed it so a decent demo of a long game is enough to enter the draw rather than completing the whole game, this should make longer games more available.
  • Play to win entries being on scraps of paper was the only thing that felt amateurish. Everything else seemed incredibly well done.
    • Whilst we take on board this feedback we used the play to wins as a way to recycle old posters and signage. We try to keep our events as eco-friendly as possible.
  • Tables were a bit tight, made it really hard for me to get in and out of my seat at times as if the person behind me wasn’t sat tucked into their table then there wasn’t enough room for me to get in. I really struggled.
    • We’ve improved the layout in 2025 onwards. There should be more space, most of the room will be accessible on the wide / wheel chair route, there will be some gaming tables in the centre.  Overall we are better than a lot of conventions which can have very long rows of tables.
    • Less tables, may mean turning guests away, as a non-ticketed, free event, managing and predicting number is a real issue. We have not found a way to ‘ticket’ the event without adding many barriers to guests.
  • There were a few interesting RPGs running at the same time as other things I wanted to play so I had to miss out on some things that interested me. Pretty much anything running at the same time as the more popular games such as BotC struggled to get enough players. Maybe see if it would be possible to plan the scheduling with this in mind?
    • Noted:  We do our best to schedule games but we are also reliant on the volunteers who are running these events and their availability.
  • Having someone to greet you as you come in. If you have never been before, you wouldn’t know that you can play any of the games in the library or that all the activities are free (eg. painting).
    • Noted: We have improved our rota coverage to reduce the the chance of a guest not being greeted. I (Adam) personally greeted most of the guests so this should have been an exception.
    • We have also improved our signage across the event. For example we have some brand new games in the library which are in shrink, so there is a sign which says please open me!

Lastly, we do welcome all and any feedback (both positive and negative) and really do appreciate it.  We have steering groups to give us feedback and to approve/improve our action plans. Ultimately we aim and work hard to help our guests to have a positive experience with us.